04:12
Why can the same coating design be quoted at twice the price? A comparison of e-beam, IAD and magnetron sputtering on density, drift, cost and application — plus what hard versus soft coating really means and how film stress bends thin substrates.
People often ask why the same coating drawing gets quoted at two hundred by one supplier and five hundred by another. The answer is usually the process.
First, why coat at all. Bare glass reflects about four percent and selects nothing. Alternate high- and low-index layers at quarter-wave thickness and the interface reflections interfere: the target wavelength adds in phase and passes, the rest cancels. More layers, steeper curve. A high-performance narrowband filter often has fifty to one hundred and fifty layers.
Process one: electron-beam evaporation. An electron beam evaporates the material onto the substrate. It is fast, cheap and works with many materials, but the film grows in a porous columnar structure that absorbs moisture. The refractive index then changes and the centre wavelength drifts — which is why some filters are off-spec after a few months.
Process two: ion-assisted deposition, IAD. An ion beam bombards the growing film and densifies it. Density approaches bulk material, drift is small, and the part survives humidity cycling and wiping. Fluorescence filters and precision optics generally use this route.
Process three: magnetron sputtering. Plasma sputters target atoms onto the substrate, giving very dense, uniform films suited to volume hard-coat production. It is less flexible for design tweaks and has a longer prototyping cycle.
There is also ion beam sputtering with the lowest loss, but it is slow and expensive — laser mirrors, not routine filters.
Hard versus soft coating: hard usually means IAD or sputtered, dense enough to wipe and pass adhesion tests; soft means plain e-beam, sensitive to wiping and moisture. The difference shows in wavelength stability, cleanability and environmental testing. Automotive and medical parts almost always require hard coatings.
One last point people forget: film stress. Dozens of layers can accumulate hundreds of megapascals. The thinner and larger the substrate, the more it bends — a tenth-wave surface can become a half-wave after coating. Fix it with stress compensation in the design, annealing after deposition, or a thicker substrate. If wavefront matters, tell your supplier before they quote.
This video has a full written version
Optical Coating Processes Explained: E-beam, IAD and Magnetron Sputtering
365nm Narrow Bandpass Filter | Ø50mm | T>90%
OT-HBP3659050
365nm Narrow Bandpass Filter; FWHM 10nm; transmission >90%; blocking OD5; size Ø50mm; AOI 0°.
450nm Narrow Bandpass Filter | Ø50mm
OT-HBP4509050
450nm Narrow Bandpass Filter; FWHM 10nm; transmission >90%; blocking OD5; size Ø50mm; AOI 0°.
525nm Narrow Bandpass Filter | Ø50mm
OT-HBP5259050
525nm Narrow Bandpass Filter; FWHM 10nm; transmission >90%; blocking OD5; size Ø50mm; AOI 0°.
Send us your drawing and spectral targets — an engineer replies with a feasibility check and quotation within one business day.