ISO 9001 Certified Manufacturer 360° Factory Tour
Wiki & Glossary

Coating Types: Hard, Soft, Ion-Assisted and Magnetron Sputtered Compared

· 1 views · 2 min read · OOTEE Optics Editorial

Original content by the OOTEE Optics editorial team, drawn from first-hand production line and inspection data. Please credit the source when republishing.

Given limits in expertise and test conditions, the theories, parameters and conclusions here carry no guarantee of absolute accuracy. For technical learning and exchange only - never the sole basis for design, acceptance or selection. Corrections welcome.

Coating Types: Hard, Soft, Ion-Assisted and Magnetron Sputtered Compared

Nine tenths of a filter's performance comes from the coating, and most of that comes from the deposition process. Two parts both labelled "532 nm narrowband, OD4" can differ severalfold in stability, lifetime and price depending on how they were made.

Main processes compared

ProcessPrincipleFilm characterTypical use
Thermal evaporation (soft)Heat the material in vacuum until it evaporates and condensesPorous columnar structure with voids; absorbs waterDecorative films, low-cost filters, general lighting
Ion-assisted deposition (IAD)Bombard the substrate with an ion beam during evaporationMuch denser, harder and more stableIndustrial filters, fluorescence filters, machine vision
Magnetron sputtering (MS)Ions knock atoms off a target, which deposit on the substrateDensest and most repeatable; stress controllableHigh-end narrowband, laser coatings, telecom
Ion beam sputtering (IBS)A separate ion source sputters the targetUltra-low loss, outstanding stabilityUltra-low-loss laser mirrors, precision metrology
Atomic layer deposition (ALD)Growth one atomic layer at a timePinhole free, perfectly conformalComplex shapes, special barrier layers

The real difference: density

In thermal evaporation the arriving atoms carry little energy and pile up like snowfall into a columnar structure full of nanoscale voids. Those voids:

  1. Absorb water: humidity changes make the voids take up or release water, changing the effective index and shifting the center wavelength - the reason a soft-coated filter reads 532 nm today and 535 nm tomorrow.
  2. Reduce hardness: a porous film marks easily when wiped.
  3. Reduce stability: performance degrades faster under thermal cycling and damp heat.

IAD and sputtering deliver far more energy to the arriving atoms, compacting the film and closing the voids, which fixes all three issues at once.

Humidity drift: the most practical test

A useful discriminator: ask how far the center wavelength drifts with humidity.

  • Soft coatings: from dry air to 90% RH, the CWL can move 0.1-0.3% (0.5-1.6 nm at 532 nm).
  • Hard coatings (IAD or sputtered): essentially no drift, often below 0.01%.

For bandwidths above 10 nm that drift may not matter; at 1-3 nm a soft-coated part is simply unusable.

Balancing cost and performance

NeedRecommended processWhy
Cost first, mild environment, wide bandThermal evaporationCheapest, performance adequate
Industrial or outdoor duty, stability neededIAD hard coatingThe best value mainstream choice
Narrowband (5 nm or less), fluorescence, lasersIAD or sputteringStable wavelength, deep blocking, repeatable
High power lasers, ultra narrow, telecomIBS or magnetron sputteringLowest loss, best stability

Common misconceptions

  • "Hard coating" means scratch proof. Hard coatings resist wiping better, but they are still thin films and aggressive wiping damages them. Always use air blowers or a gentle solvent wipe, never dry rubbing.
  • Trusting the process name alone. Two vendors' "IAD" can differ enormously in parameters and materials. Judge by measured curves and environmental test data.
  • Ignoring film stress. Denser films usually carry more stress and can bend the substrate, especially thin parts - a factor to balance when the figure matters.

How to specify

If you are unsure which process to name, specify the result, not the process:

"IAD or equivalent hard coating; center wavelength shift no more than 0.5 nm between 23 C/45% RH and 40 C/90% RH; pass 48 hour damp heat test."

Verifiable requirements beat process names and leave the supplier room to optimize. For process detail see the complete guide to optical coating processes.

Need a process and cost comparison? Send band, bandwidth, environment and quantity to sales@ootee.cn.

Related Reading

View all

Related Products

View all products

Need a custom optical filter?

Send us your drawing and spectral targets — an engineer replies with a feasibility check and quotation within one business day.

Source Factory In-house coating lines, no middlemen
Ready to Ship Standard items dispatched same or next day
Quality Guaranteed 100 % inspected, spectral report included
Express Delivery DHL / FedEx worldwide